I took the book on Deng Xiaoping I reluctantly bought in the evening and read the first page of vile points of view from the Oxford published writer. It reeks of insult, like calling Xiaoping's father "Papa Deng" with the slanderous teenage implication, Mr. Shit, but most facts can't be disputed; only half truths. I'm glad I saved $10 from the listed price. It will be put on the shelf next to the book on Lin Piao from Martin Ebon’s dated Lin Piao; The Life and Writings of China’s New Ruler, that at least has half the pages filled with actual speeches, meant mockingly, but the two men couldn't be more ideologically different. Piao almost destroyed China's revolution with too-much too-soon radicalism. Deng saved China from itself.
I started reading the Deng Xiaoping book by Alexander V. Pantsov (with Steven I. Levine) I got on sale at a bookstore in Taipei. They didn't have the 825 page Deng biography I wanted; I am not buying anything on eBay until the international mail is back to normal. Interestingly, in the introduction, the author makes a case for their biography over the one I would have preferred to read saying their version covers Deng's whole life while the other concentrates on his last twenty-seven years. His book uses research from Russia and China that Ezra F. Vogel's book didn't have access to. He says Vogel was “quite uncritical and lacking in objectivity” of Deng claiming his book is more balanced about Deng's accomplishments and drawbacks, but so far I only see anti-China propaganda and half-truths if not out-and-out lies about the youthful “streets of blood” in Tienanmen and other two “T” (Taiwan, Tibet) of western slander about China; but that was in 2015. He could have added a H.K. and X (Hong Kong and Xinjiang) if it were published five years later. Alas, this was the only book they had in English about Deng and not the “uncritical and unrealistically positive” one I wanted, but this is Taiwan and rarely anything good about China can be found in media. At least this bio should have facts and quotes from Deng. I can peel away the bullshit and chuckle at the attempt to defame China comparing it to the 'high standards' of US democracy. I wonder what the book would say if written after China’s successful fight against coronavirus and the U.S. falling into chaos and fascism.
The gossipy anti-communist biography by A.V. Pantsov and S.I. Levine about Deng Xiaoping; A Revolutionary Life is horribly immature. I’d much rather have the respectful Deng Xiaoping and the Transformation of China by Ezra F. Vogel, and I finally found it on the bookstore shelf in Taiwan. The imperialist, racist, regressive bias of history written by Western academics disgusts me.
October 23, 2020
Visit My Website
Copyright © 2020 by David Barry Temple. All rights reserved
No comments:
Post a Comment